File:Pic 138d0f5b19a2e1f38f3c64e54de.jpg
Survivor:Mystery Island was the 13th Season of the Cmack's Survivor Franchise. It began on August 16, 2011 and concluded on September 20, 2011

It was won by DEADBEATJONAH14 who defeated former winner BBlover96 and rshowfreak in a 7-4-0 vote. BBlover96 won the "Player of the Season" award with over 70% of the votes.

This season was dubbed as "Redemption Island #2" and was claimed to be 1 of the most competitive of Cmack's Seasons.

Contestant Original Tribe Switched Tribe Merged Tribe Voted Out Redemption Island Mystsry Island Finish
jbmbb11 Taino 1st Duel 1 Loser Duel 1 Loser 24thBbwbx Taino 2nd Duel 2 Loser Duel 2 Loser 23rd
TheGreat Taino 5th Duel 5 Loser Duel 3 Loser 22nd
taylor112399 Akan 6th Duel 6 Loser Duel 4 Loser 21st
Taino 7th Duel 7 er Duel 5 Loser 20th flamergamer8 Akan Akan style="text-align: c Duel Taino Akan 11th Returned Duel 7 Loser 18th Gaiaphage Taino Taino 12th lol


16th Duel 13 Loser Duel 11 Loser 14th
BestHeroD Taino NONE** 18th Returned Duel 12 Loser 13th
Keitho44 NONE* Akan 15th Duel 12 Loser Duel 13 Loser 12th
MHens Akan Akan 20th Duel 14 Loser Duel 14 Loser 11th
Samoa Akan Akan 19th Duel 14 Loser Duel 15 Loser 10th
Endo360 Taino Akan 21st Duel 15 Loser Duel 16 Loser 9th
survivorpika99 NONE* Akan 24th Duel 17 Loser Duel 17 Loser 8th


NONE* Taino 25th Duel 18 Loser Duel 18 Loser 7th
NatalieRoux Akan Taino 26th Duel 19 Loser Duel 19 Loser 6th
bingo21 Taino Taino 27th Duel 16 Loser Returned 5th
UndercoverMonk Taino Taino 28th Returned 4th
RShowFreak NONE* Taino Finalist Returned 3rd
BBlover96 Akan Akan Finalist Returned 2nd
DEADBEATJONAH14 Akan Akan Finalist Survivor
  • The Mystery 4 did not enter the game until after the Tribe Swap, therefore they never were on the original tribes.
  • BestHeroD was voted off his orignal tribe and didn't return until the Merge.

Season Summary

20 players began a journey of a lifetime! 10 Veterans of Cmack's Survivor along with 10 Newbies. Each group of 10 faced an opening challenge to determine the Tribe Leaders. Gaiaphage and BBlover96 each won and they were instructed to pick each member of their new Tribes(Taino, Akan)

Several twists were revealed at the start. Mystery Island would be in play. After somebody is voted out and loses on Redemption Island, they head to Mystery Island where if they lose, they will be eliminated. The Mystery 4 consisting of 4 previous players including 3 former finalists and 1 winner.

To start the game off, the tribes were each divided. Taino lost 3/4 immunity challenges resulting in jbmbb11, Zed55, and jag0827 being voted out. On Akan, jogo248 located an immunity idol and with some help from Samoa, blindsided BBlover96.

With 4 Vets voted out early, the Newbies had the numbers. After BestHeroD played an idol, TheGreat was voted out on Taino while another Vet, taylor112399 was voted out on Akan.

cdbaumgarth, BestHeroD, and flamergamer8 were the next 3 snuffed while the 1st 4 eliminated came face to face with the Mystery 4(RShow, soccer, pika, Keitho). A 4 vs 4 Duel resulted in the Mystery 4 entering the game with safety until the Final 14.

BBlover96 and jag0827 each won 5 Duels and returned only to be voted out immediately.

After a Tribe Swap and the addition of the Mystery 4, swing votes were determining the votes and the power players were in trouble.

Gaiaphage was blindsided over jogo248 at the next Tribal Council. Inactives noraw6842 and zac15 were voted out and subsequently eliminated soon after.

On Day 16, the 14 remaining players were all Merged into 1 tribe(Akanomoco)

A Secret 6 Alliance of bingo, Natalie, MHens, jogo, soccer, and Endo was formed and they controlled the 1st Post-Merge vote with Keitho44 being voted out with an idol in his pocket.

After DEADBEATJONAH14 found out about the Secret 6, the alliance began to fall apart.

1st, jogo248 was voted out. After RShow and BestHeroD were voted out, a twist sent the game into a frenzy.

Samoa was voted out, and UndercoverMonk got a Sole Vote and blindsided MHens.

The next 3 votes resulted in the Final Newbies getting voted out(Endo, bingo, Monk).

With the un-official Final 6 all Veterans, survivorpika99 and soccerbchris were blindsided.

When 4 were left, RShow and Natalie were tied in a vote that RShow won a tie breaker challenge.

After Monk and bingo returned, the FINAL 5 were official.

On Day 34, RShowFreak won the final 2 immunity challenges. At the F5 vote, Monk was supposedly targetted as bingo played an idol on him...but bingo was voted out instead. Moments later, UndercoverMonk lost to DEADBEAT in a Tie Breaker becoming the Final Jury Member of the season.

At Jury Questioning, all 3 players were bashed by the Jury. BBlover96 was bashed for being very cocky during the 1st half of the game and being voted out twice. DEADBEAT was bashed for alligning with most of the Jury and turning on them to advance his own game. RShowFreak was bashed for being safe for half of the game and entering later than all the others.

In the end, the Jury awarded DEADBEAT the title of Sole Survivor over BBlover96 and RShowFreak in a 7-4-0 vote.

Voting History
Day 1 2 3 4 6 7 8 9 10 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 23 24 28 29 30 33
Voted Out
DEADBEATJONAH14 jogo248 taylor112399 flamergamer8 BBlover96 jag0827 Kidnapped
BBlover96 jogo248 On Redemption Island flamergamer8 Samoa On Redemption Island
RShowFreak Gaiaphage noraw6842
UndercoverMonk jbmbb11 Zed55 jag0827 TheGreat Endo360 cdbaumgarth BestHeroD jogo248 noraw6842
bingo21 jbmbb11 Zed55 jag0827 BestHeroD Endo360 cdbaumgarth BestHeroD jogo248 noraw6842
NatalieRoux jogo248 taylor112399 Gaiaphage bingo21
soccerbchris Gaiaphage noraw6842
survivorpika99 Samoa zac15 zac15
Endo360 jbmbb11 Zed55 Endo360 TheGreat cdbaumgarth TIED BestHeroD flamergamer8 BBlover96 jag0827 zac15
Samoa BBlover96 taylor112399 BBlover96 BBlover96 jag0827 Endo360
MHens BBlover96 taylor112399 flamergamer8 BBlover96 jag0827 zac15
Keitho44 Samoa zac15 zac15
BestHeroD Gaiaphage TheGreat Endo360 Endo360 Gaiaphage Gaiaphage Gaiaphage On Mystery Island
jogo248 BBlover96 taylor112399 Gaiaphage Kidnapped
zac15 zac15 zac15 Exiled zac15 zac15 zac15
noraw6842 noraw6842 taylor112399 Gaiaphage bingo21
Gaiaphage jbmbb11 Gaiaphage jag0827 TheGreat cdbaumgarth TIED BestHeroD jogo248
jag0827 jbmbb11 BestHeroD BestHeroD Endo360
flamergamer8 flamergamer8 flamergamer8 flamergamer8
cdbaumgarth jbmbb11 Zed55 BestHeroD BestHeroD
taylor112399 jogo248 zac15
TheGreat Gaiaphage TheGreat Gaiaphage TheGreat Gaiaphage TIED
Zed55 cdbaumgarth cdbaumgarth
jbmbb11 jbmbb11